Congresswoman Maxine Dexter, M.D. Introduces Bill that Codifies and Prevents Conflicts of Interest on Key Health Prevention Board
WASHINGTON, D.C. – Congresswoman Maxine Dexter, M.D. (OR-03) introduced Protect USPSTF Integrity Act codify standards and norms for candidates nominated to the United States Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF). The measure would restore membership qualifications to historic standards, requiring qualified candidates to be free of any outside financial or other – conflict of interest. U.S. Representatives Kelly Morrison (D-MN) and Herbert Conaway (D-NJ) are original cosponsors. U.S. Senators Angus King (I-ME) and Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) introduced the bill in the Senate.
The legislation comes on the heels of new revelations that half of the eight recent appointees for this important panel have needed waivers for financial conflicts. Last month, Senator King led his colleagues in a letter to HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. asking him to explain his abrupt overhaul of the USPSTF, appointing eight new members whose qualifications fall short of the traditional standards of training in prevention and primary care medicine.
“We must not allow undermining the health of the American people to become a path to corrupt self-enrichment,” said Congresswoman Maxine Dexter, M.D. “The United States Preventive Services Task Force should be solely focused on ensuring preventive care is grounded in science—not enriching task force members and their affiliates. I am proud to put forth legislation that will protect the integrity of this task force, to make sure no conflicts of interest influence how this group operates or makes decisions."
“The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force has been effective for over forty years because it has let science and data lead our nation’s decisions and guidance when it comes to prevention medicine,” said Senator King. “While there is certainly much to be gained from subject matter experts and professionals closely tied to the private sector, those voices should be invited to the panel’s work in limited cases where their biases or motivations wouldn’t overshadow the nation’s healthcare work. This bill gets the USPSTF back on track doing the people’s work without fear or favor.”
"With all the concern on high health care costs, insured people particularly prize that preventive care is covered without cost sharing, but that needs to be protected from attack from this administration," said Anthony Wright, executive director of Families USA. "The recent upheaval to the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force threatens the guarantee that covers such care. We support legislation and oversight to ensure an independent Task Force, which is crucial for a strong health system of primary and preventive care. When HHS can rewrite recommendations to fit its political priorities, families pay the price with medical debt and worse health outcomes. Senator King’s bill protects the Task Force’s legacy of independence and expertise, and with it, the processes that guarantee preventive care is covered without cost-sharing."
“Americans make real decisions about their health based on Task Force recommendations, from cancer screenings to blood pressure checks,” said AcademyHealth President and CEO Aaron Carroll, M.D., M.S. “Those recommendations earn their weight because they rest on transparent, rigorous, independent review of the science. We commend Senator King’s leadership in putting durable and nonpartisan safeguards around that process.”
More specifically, the Protect USPSTF Integrity Act would:
- Revert to historic membership qualifications prioritizing membership expertise in preventive and primary care medicine;
- Codify standards for meeting frequency in line with previous standards;
- Create standards for conflicts of interest and requiring relevant recusal;
- Codify the historic standards and procedures manual (published April 2023), and requiring public input for any relevant Task Force changes; and
- Prevent the Secretary from changing Task Force recommendations on the basis that it no longer effectuates Departmental standards;
Created in 1984, the USPSTF has been solely comprised of primary care providers and experts in broad, general prevention medicine. Specialists have been brought in when needed on Task Force recommendations but have never been selected as USPSTF members in part to prevent conflicts of interest.
Read one-pager here.
Read bill text here.
###